Dec 14th

2012

Shooting in Black & White

I couldn’t bring myself to shoot a single black and white image in Antarctica last year. To me the place was all about colour. This year it was very different. Last week I was on Deception Island in Antarctica, walking around an old whaling station in the crater of a still-active volcano. It’s a fascinating place, full of texture, contrasts, and decaying ghosts of the past. Last year’s weather was so different and the colours were so rich, but this year I began to feel the place in black and white. I want to tell you I saw the place in black & white, but I didn’t. I felt it. To see it I needed the camera’s help. Shooting in colour so much,  I just don’t see in black and white so well these days.

I set my Nikons to shoot in black and white, taking my cues from the LCD screen to get a sense for the scene, at least for a while as I re-learned what the world looks like rendered that way. When shooting in RAW, remember that when you look at the preview on the LCD you’re only looking at a small JPG version of the image. In this case, that JPG is shown in monochrome, but the RAW file is still there in all it’s full-data, full-colour glory. When you later bring the image into Lightroom or Aperture you’ll still have to do a great black and white conversion, but for anyone with difficulty seeing in monochrome, this is helpful.

Here’s how to do it simply, with a couple button-clicks on two cameras, a Nikon D800 and a Canon 5D Mk II.

On the Nikon: Menu > Shooting Menu (Camera Icon) > Set Picture Control > MC Monochrome. If you want to step it up a notch and customize this monochrome setting, like for instance, adding a tone, or more contrast, then it’s Menu > Manage Picture Control, and follow the rabbit trail to tweak the settings and create a custom picture style.

On the Canon: Menu > Picture Style (Second Red Camera icon) > Monochrome. If you want to customize it, you follow the same menu prompts, but instead of choosing Monochrome (or Standard, Neutral…) head down to one of the User Def. settings and you can tweak and save one of those.

Some of the newer cameras with electronic viewfinders take this a step further and allow you to see the scene in black and white even before you shoot it. My Fuji x100 did this for me, so did my little Leica point and shoot a few years ago. I suspect the newer xPro 1 and most of the micro 4/3 cameras do it, too. Once you’ve been shooting in black and white a while it becomes easier to see the scene in monochrome, but colour can be really seductive hard to see past; for those of us who primarily work in colour, making the switch to seeing in black & white can benefit from a little help.

If, once you’re back into Lightroom 4, you need a little help with the black &white conversions, my Lightroom 4 Develop Presets contain some solid starting points to help you get going. The Craft & Vision library also has some excellent books on the subject, all for just $5.

Comments (9)
  1. December 14, 2012 at 8:46 am

    Thank you for the tip David, this is just what I was pondering. Both images are evocative, especially the second one. I take it the crosses mark graves, just wondered who they were?

  2. December 14, 2012 at 9:02 am

    And thank you! I never thought to do that when wanting to shoot in B&W. It actually would’ve helped me a lot last night.

  3. vasily

    December 14, 2012 at 9:04 am

    As someone with virtually no color perception, this is a really fascinating read! I can talk all about gear, or composition, and even lighting. But once color is introduced, I’m helpless and rely on the camera, custom WB cards, and my friends to get it right!

  4. Nate Parker

    December 14, 2012 at 9:11 am

    I love the first shot- there’s just something awesome about how black and white makes silos and tanks look incredible- I think maybe it’s how the light wraps around the curves. So where I almost always use a black and white shooting mode what I find frustrating is how upon import the mono settings are replaced with the original color scene- of course I’ll always work a monochrome image off of its color version then send it to Silver Efex- I’d rather not have to make a Lightroom black and white conversion for all of the outtakes- but there isn’t just one LR b+w preset that suits every image for me. I’ve experimented time and again with trying to pick one style of LR mono preset or making my own- just wish there was an option to retain the original jpeg mono settings from the camera. Yes. Right then. Happy Holidays Mr! -Nate.

  5. December 15, 2012 at 2:57 pm

    Hi David, i got it now! :) that’s true – not everybody can see and feel world full of colors in b/w on the fly :) have to try that way of taking photos out – i believe it will be really useful :) thanks!!! cheers, m.

  6. December 16, 2012 at 7:23 am

    Sometimes, I have really big problem to shoot colour or B&W. When both versions have their advantages, then you need to take the BIG decision

  7. December 16, 2012 at 4:08 pm

    Using that B&W “preview” feature might be useful for creating better color photos, too. Painting instructors and books often suggest taking a B&W photos of your work, to help isolate and analyze use of tones. And it really does help. I’m going to set my camera up and give it a try. Thanks for the how-to for the 5D!